Skip to content

Employment Law – Sexual Harassment

Merely setting up reporting channels within a company is not enough to avoid compensation for sexual harassment

When sexual harassment occurs in the workplace, the Federal Supreme Court, in its judgment of 15 March 2023 (4A_283/2022), recognises that the mere introduction of various reporting mechanisms is not sufficient to provide the exculpatory proof under Art. 5 para. 3 of the Federal Act on Gender Equality (Gender Equality Act, GEA). In order to comply with its duty of prevention and protection, the employer must also ensure that those in charge have a proper command of these mechanisms, that employees are aware of them and that the reporting procedure is duly conducted.

At the 2017 Christmas party organised by a bank (hereinafter: the employer), a female employee was asked her bra size and had her bottom groped twice by a colleague. That colleague had previously already put inappropriate questions and remarks to her.

In the course of 2018, the employee complained of sexual harassment to human resources and initiated an internal complaints procedure to report her situation. While she was unable to work due to illness from 19 July 2018 to 31 March 2019, the employer decided, on 15 January 2019, to terminate her employment contract with effect from 31 March on the grounds of a breakdown of the relationship of trust following her complaint, which the employer, after an inquiry and an internal investigation, had found to be unfounded.

On the grounds that it had failed in its duty to prevent and properly investigate the harassment suffered by its employee, the employer was ordered by the Chambre des prud’hommes of the Geneva Cour de justice, on 12 March 2021, to pay her compensation for sexual harassment (CHF 6’502.-) and for wrongful termination (CHF 31’7619.-). Almost two years later, the Federal Supreme Court upheld that ruling and dismissed the appeal lodged by the employer.

The employer’s main argument, rejected by our highest court, rested on the exculpatory proof under Art. 5 para. 3 GEA. Under that provision, an employer that takes the measures that have been proven in practice to be necessary, that are adequate in the circumstances and that it could reasonably have been expected to take in order to prevent and put an end to acts of sexual harassment suffered by an employee may exceptionally be released from liability and, consequently, from paying any compensation for harassment.

Endorsing the reasoning of the cantonal court, the Federal Supreme Court first recognises that the mere introduction of various reporting mechanisms against harassment is insufficient to be released from paying the compensation for harassment claimed by an employee.

In essence, the employer had introduced three tools, namely (1) the employer’s internal anti-harassment directive, which had been consulted only six times, was difficult to access on the intranet and contained a complaint form in small print that appeared only implicitly on its penultimate page, (2) an external assistance programme advertised by posters displayed, in particular, in the bank’s cafeterias, although those posters made no reference to sexual harassment, and (3) a reporting tool that did not mention the issue of sexual harassment.

The employer did indeed have these three tools, but how to use them had not been mastered and was even unknown to the staff. They had been presented to employees only very superficially, and the bank’s line managers were clearly unaware of the internal procedure to be followed when sexual harassment was reported, which revealed a significant lack of diligence.

Again following the reasoning of the cantonal court, the Federal Supreme Court then recognises the importance, for any business, of conducting a reporting procedure that is respectful of the complainant and a diligent internal investigation, failing which it will not be released from paying compensation for harassment.

In the present case, the bank had indeed failed to fulfil its duty to protect the employee by subjecting her to a surprise confrontation with her aggressor, despite the state of shock she was in on her arrival, which brought her to tears. Although she was the only woman among three men, the head of human resources, who had not offered her the presence of a woman on the panel of examiners, decided to go ahead with the confrontation as it stood. As for the internal investigation conducted by the employer, no minutes had been kept of the witness hearings and it had been conducted by a single person only. Finally, the employer failed to appoint a person of trust of the same sex as the employee to accompany her throughout the process following her complaint.

For these reasons, notwithstanding the introduction of various reporting mechanisms, the employer could not rely on the exculpatory proof under Art. 5 para. 3 GEA to avoid paying compensation for sexual harassment.

It should also be noted that, in casu, the compensation for sexual harassment is kept at one month’s average Swiss salary (CHF 6’502) because the employee could have been more proactive in reporting the harassment she suffered.

Accordingly, the appeal is dismissed insofar as it is admissible.

The content of this article does not constitute legal advice. One of the following lawyers will be pleased to advise you on your particular situation: