Skip to content

Public service law

The inspection of a civil servant’s computer is not open to appeal

In its judgment of 19 February 2024 (1C_447/2023), the Federal Supreme Court held that the individualised monitoring of a civil servant’s computer does not allow her to claim a current and practical interest worthy of protection in obtaining an immediate finding that the monitoring was unlawful on the basis of Art. 4A of the Geneva Administrative Procedure Act (LPA) (“right to an appealable act”; our translation).

At the request of the human resources manager, the Secretary General of the cantonal Department of Social Cohesion gave her approval for the Cantonal Office for Information Systems and Digital Technology to carry out individualised monitoring of a civil servant’s computer covering the period from March 2019 to December 2022.

The monitoring was requested in order to verify allegations made against the civil servant, who had allegedly, among other things:

  • regularly consulted the Calvin application to obtain information about third parties,
  • spent a great deal of time on the Internet,
  • carried out numerous private activities during her working hours and
  • clocked her working hours incorrectly.

The above allegations were confirmed; consequently, the civil servant’s line management informed her that termination of her employment relationship for valid reasons was being considered.

The appellant requested notification of a formal ruling within the meaning of Art. 4A LPA, subject to appeal and stating, in particular, the grounds on which the monitoring had been authorised. Her request was refused, first, on the ground that the monitoring had been carried out in accordance with the legal framework and, secondly, because there was no legal interest in a declaratory ruling being issued, since such a ruling was subsidiary to a later ruling to be issued in the administrative proceedings concerning a possible termination of her employment relationship.

By judgment of 9 August 2023, the Administrative Chamber of the Court of Justice of the Republic and Canton of Geneva declared inadmissible the appeal for denial of justice lodged by the civil servant on 8 May 2023, on the ground that the monitoring constituted an internal administrative act not subject to appeal, without consequence for the civil servant, since she could assert her right to be heard in the pending administrative proceedings.

The Federal Supreme Court dismissed the civil servant’s appeal against that judgment, holding that:

  • the right to a declaratory ruling is subsidiary in nature and does not come into consideration if legal protection can be ensured in another way,
  • a dispute must in principle be submitted to the court as a whole; the person concerned cannot choose to isolate legal questions in order to submit them separately to the court,
  • the appellant learned of the results of the monitoring during a service meeting (entretien de service) and was able to state her position on them and
  • there is nothing to suggest that the appellant will be unable, in the pending administrative proceedings, to have a violation of her rights established, together with the fact that the monitoring of her computer was unlawful and its results unusable, in order to oppose a possible termination of her employment relationship.

Accordingly, the appellant could not claim a current and practical interest worthy of protection in obtaining an immediate finding that the monitoring of her computer was unlawful on the basis of Art. 4A LPA.

The Court therefore considered that it was not necessary, in particular, to examine whether the monitoring affected the civil servant’s rights and obligations towards the State, whether it was an internal administrative act not subject to appeal, or whether the appellant could use another legal remedy to assert her rights.

Consequently, the appeal is dismissed insofar as it is admissible.

The content of this article does not constitute legal advice. One of the following lawyers will be pleased to advise you on your particular situation: