Skip to content

Public service law

In the absence of an appealable act, an appeal against a meeting between a civil servant and line management is declared inadmissible

In its judgment of 16 January 2024 (ATA/43/2024), the Administrative Chamber of the Court of Justice of the Republic and Canton of Geneva (hereinafter: the Administrative Chamber), in the absence of an appealable act, declared inadmissible the appeal lodged by a civil servant against a service meeting (entretien de service) held in his presence and that of his line management.

Indeed, the following do not constitute rulings subject to appeal: the minutes of a meeting between the civil servant and his line management, confirmed by a letter written a few days later; the change of assignment, which does not meet the strict conditions for constituting a ruling; the position taken by line management on a request for a salary evaluation, since it consists, in casu, of a transmission of information; the staff appraisal and development interview and the additional elements it contains; and finally, the absence of a ruling by the respondent authority on the protection of the employee’s personality, since he did not follow the specific procedure provided for that purpose and, consequently, there was no measure by the Groupe de confiance (the unit responsible for protecting the personality of the Geneva cantonal administration’s staff) requiring such a ruling to be issued.

Summary

Against a background of tensions within the security department, the appellant civil servant, who holds the position of caretaker, repeatedly asked his line management to take measures to protect his personality. Following his request, the appellant was received for meetings several times in the presence of his director, in particular on 7 March 2023.

At that meeting, the appellant described his difficulties in working with the security department and reiterated his request for support from his line management.

As a guarantee of swift change, the director suggested moving the employee elsewhere if he so wished, as she saw no other alternative. He replied that he did not wish to be moved by way of punishment.

The director assured the civil servant of her support and acknowledged his work and professional conscientiousness. While the substance of the matters raised by the appellant was important, his manner of communicating was not always appropriate.

On 11 May 2023, the appellant’s staff appraisal and development interview (entretien d’évaluation et de développement du personnel, hereinafter “EEDP”) was held in the presence of the new head of service: his appraisal was positive. He stated that he was not satisfied with the distribution of the workload, the working resources and his salary class, which is why he requested an urgent reassessment.

On 2 June 2023, the appellant wrote to his director to inform her, first, that he objected to any relocation of his workstation and, secondly, that he was reiterating his request for a salary increase, which was to take effect within one month.

In a document dated 22 June 2023, the appellant’s director and head of service made amendments to the EEDP of 11 May 2023, mainly concerning his manner of communicating, which was considered at times inappropriate or somewhat abrupt. In addition, three further objectives were set, relating to communication, mandatory training for the post and attendance at mandatory meetings.

On 23 June 2023, a meeting took place between the appellant, the director and the head of service, covering three points, namely the letter of 2 June 2023, the appellant’s situation and the EEDP. The meeting was recorded in an internal memo serving as minutes, which the director sent to the appellant by email on 28 June 2023.

On 30 June 2023, the appellant expressed to the director his deep disappointment regarding the meeting of 23 June 2023 and the subsequent exchanges. He requested a formal ruling on his requests for a finding that his personality rights had been infringed, for protection of his personality and for equal pay, and on a disciplinary sanction, should such a measure be envisaged against him.

He reiterated his request on 15 July 2023, setting the management a deadline of 22 July 2023 to issue a ruling.

On 19 July 2023, the appellant lodged an appeal with the Administrative Chamber against the ruling of 23 June 2023, confirmed in writing on 28 June 2023, issued by the director and the head of service.

He sought its annulment, a finding that his personality rights had been infringed since 2014, payment by the department of CHF 45,000 by way of reparation, a prohibition of the infringement of his personality rights, a change to his salary class and payment of equitable compensation in that respect.

The department submitted that the appeal was inadmissible for lack of an appealable act.

This case gave the Chamber the opportunity to recall the conditions required for an appealable act to exist, clarifying in particular the distinction between a ruling and an internal administrative act. While the former seeks to alter the legal situation of private individuals, the latter concerns situations within the administration; it may admittedly have legal effects, but that is not its purpose.

On that basis, the Chamber examined the question of the change of assignment, which, in principle, falls within the internal management of the administration. That said, a change of assignment constitutes an appealable ruling where it:

  1. is liable to infringe the employee’s personality rights;
  2. is such as to undermine the employee’s standing, in particular with regard to his or her abilities;
  3. amounts to a disguised sanction, it being specified that the conditions for accepting such a sanction are strict and, for example, are not met where the salary is unchanged and the new post falls within the civil servant’s areas of competence.

In the present case, however, the discussion about a possible change in the appellant’s place of work took place in the context of workplace conflicts; such a measure could enable the appellant to continue his professional activity in good working conditions and thus forms part of the usual powers of the person responsible for staff management, who must ensure the protection of the personality of his or her subordinate and the proper functioning of the service.

Since the appellant keeps his job within the same office, with duties matching his abilities and with no change to his salary, this is neither a disguised sanction nor a change in his legal situation.

Accordingly, no ruling subject to appeal was issued on this point.

Next, the Chamber ruled on the appellant’s request for a salary reassessment. His line management had stated that such a request must be based on objective grounds, such as additional training or specific features of the post, and that in the absence of such elements, no steps could be taken.

The Chamber held that line management’s position amounted to a transmission of information, without seeking to alter the appellant’s legal situation; it therefore did not constitute an appealable act.

As regards the staff appraisal and development interview of 11 May 2023 and the additional elements added to it, they do not seek to alter the appellant’s legal situation either, but to inform him of his line management’s expectations. They therefore do not constitute a ruling subject to appeal, even where there is a written record.

Finally, the Chamber recalled that implementing the personality protection scheme within the cantonal administration falls within the remit of the Groupe de confiance. A staff member who considers that he or she is experiencing significant difficulties in working relationships with other people may refer the matter to it.

The Groupe de confiance then has several tools at its disposal, ranging from informal steps to the drafting of a substantiated report on a possible infringement of personality rights. That report is the necessary prerequisite for the appointing authority to issue a ruling subject to appeal concerning an infringement of personality rights.

In the present case, there is no measure by the Groupe de confiance requiring the respondent authority to issue a ruling.

Consequently, in the absence of an appealable act, the appeal is inadmissible.

The content of this article does not constitute legal advice. One of the following lawyers will be pleased to advise you on your particular situation: