Skip to content

Art Law – Cultural Heritage with a Problematic Past

Historically problematic cultural heritage: a Commission serving museums and private individuals

On 18 September 2026, the Commission for Historically Problematic Cultural Heritage adopted its Rules of Procedure, providing not only museums and heritage institutions but also private individuals with a welcome independent tool for handling disputes concerning historically problematic cultural property. A spotlight on how it works and what it offers.

A new avenue for resolving disputes over historically problematic cultural property

The Commission for Historically Problematic Cultural Heritage (hereinafter the Commission) forms part of the Swiss legislature’s aim to regulate the import of cultural property into Switzerland, its transit and export, and the return of cultural property located in Switzerland (Art. 1 para. 1 CPTA). Its primary purpose is to help preserve the cultural heritage of mankind and to prevent the theft, looting and illicit import and export of cultural property (Art. 1 para. 2 CPTA).

Historically problematic cultural property is cultural property whose provenance or ownership raises questions because of transfers of rights in the context of National Socialism or colonialism (cf. Art. 2 paras 1 and 2bis of the Federal Act on the International Transfer of Cultural Property, hereinafter CPTA). The concept is to be understood broadly and includes, for example, human remains (cf. Explanatory Notes to the Rules of Procedure, p. 2).

The Commission was designed to address two broad categories of situations involving historically problematic cultural property – which is unique in Europe: on the one hand, looting and forced transfers linked to National Socialism – already at the heart of international discussions for several years – and, on the other, acquisitions made in colonial contexts, which have become a major subject of ethical and political debate (human remains, ritual objects, collections assembled in the context of unequal power relations).

Bringing together experts with diverse skills, the Commission is able to take into account different perspectives on the dispute brought before it and to formulate its recommendations independently and objectively.

Museums, institutions, individuals: who can bring a case before the Commission?

The Commission has two main tasks. First, it advises the Federal Council and the Federal Administration on matters relating to historically problematic cultural heritage and on how to deal with historically problematic cultural property owned by the Swiss Confederation (cf. Art. 18a para. 2 let. a and b CPTA). Second, on request, it issues non-binding recommendations in individual cases (cf. Art. 18a para. 2 let. c CPTA and Art. 1 of the CPCH Rules of Procedure), or may propose mediation.

In carrying out this task, it only considers a case where there is a sufficient connection with Switzerland. There are several connecting factors: the cultural property being located in Switzerland when the request is filed, the change of ownership having taken place in Switzerland (cf. Art. 2 para. 1 CPCH Rules of Procedure), and a connection with Switzerland credibly established by the applicant (cf. Art. 2 para. 2 CPCH Rules of Procedure). For example, the Commission will consider a case if a Swiss national played a decisive role in the change of ownership of the property (ibid.).

As a rule, the Commission does not examine a case that is or has been the subject of court proceedings or of proceedings before another commission, whether public or private, in Switzerland or abroad (cf. Art. 3 para. 1 CPCH Rules).

In practice, a case may be brought before the Commission by natural persons as well as by museums, collections or the bodies responsible for them (Art. 18a para. 2 let. c CPTA; see also Art. 4 OCPCP).

As regards the consent of the owner of the cultural property to the referral (cf. Art. 5 of the Ordinance on the Commission for Historically Problematic Cultural Heritage, OCPCP), it is generally required. However, it is not required for requests filed by natural persons or by museums or collections or the public bodies responsible for them where they concern cultural property that originates from the context of National Socialism and is owned by a museum or collection whose operation is publicly funded, or is held there on permanent loan (cf. Art. 5 para. 2 OCPCP).

A case is formally brought before the Commission by filing a written request (cf. Art. 4 CPCH Rules). Where the procedure requires the consent of the current owners, that consent must be evidenced in the request (cf. Art. 4 para. 2 CPCH Rules). A joint request may also be filed (ibid.).

The request must also establish a credible claim to ownership of the disputed cultural property and show that reasonable efforts have been made to reach a settlement and to investigate the provenance of the cultural property (cf. Art. 18a para. 4 CPTA and Art. 3 para. 3 CPCH Rules). The notion of a “claim to ownership” is to be interpreted broadly (individual property rights, collective, cultural or identity-related ties to the property; cf. Explanatory Notes to the CPCH Rules of Procedure, p. 3).

Once the written request has been filed, the President acknowledges receipt and carries out a formal examination of the request (Art. 5 para. 1 CPCH Rules), during which its admissibility is assessed.

The request is treated confidentially (ibid.). However, in order to respect the parties’ right to be heard, the President of the Commission informs the parties as soon as the procedure is opened and gives them the opportunity to state their position (cf. Art. 5 para. 3 and Art. 18a para. 4 CPTA).

The Commission conducts the procedure. However, it does not seek to take the place of the parties; in particular, it does not carry out provenance research and does not assume tasks incumbent on the parties (cf. Explanatory Notes to the CPCH Rules of Procedure, p. 4).

Mediation or recommendations: two paths to a just and fair solution

The Commission offers two ways of resolving the dispute submitted to it. It is for the President of the Commission to decide whether to invite the parties to mediation – in other words, to seek an amicable settlement – or to proceed directly with the procedure leading to recommendations (cf. Art. 5 para. 4).

Mediation – which is conducted orally and in the presence of the parties (cf. Art. 6 para. 4) – aims to find amicable solutions. The Commission does not make any recommendation in the context of mediation (cf. Art. 6 para. 2).

Mediation is cooperative and governed by the principle of ex officio investigation (cf. Explanatory Notes to the CPCH Rules of Procedure, p. 5; cf. Arts 12 and 13 APA).

If an agreement is reached, the procedure is closed (cf. Art. 6 para. 5) and the amicable settlement is recorded in writing. If no agreement is reached, the matter moves on to the procedure leading to recommendations (cf. Art. 6 para. 5).

It should be noted that statements and proposals made in mediation are strictly confidential and may therefore not be used in any subsequent recommendation procedure (cf. Explanatory Notes, p. 6).

The procedure leading to recommendations is conducted in writing in its first phase (cf. Art. 7 para. 1 CPCH Rules), followed by a hearing before the Commission. The President decides on evidentiary measures and on any further exchange of written submissions (cf. Art. 7 para. 2 CPCH Rules). The hearing before the Commission is held in the presence of the parties and in camera (cf. Art. 7 para. 3 CPCH Rules).

The procedure leading to recommendations is governed by the principle of production of evidence (cf. Art. 55 CPC; cf. Explanatory Notes to the CPCH Rules of Procedure, p. 5). Consequently, the Commission does not establish the facts of its own motion: it is for the parties to allege the facts and produce the evidence (cf. Explanatory Notes, p. 6).

As for the recommendations themselves, they are based on international instruments (cf. Art. 8 CPCH Rules). Their content covers all aspects of the case (cf. Art. 9 CPCH Rules).

In particular, the Commission may recommend to the parties the restitution of the cultural property; the division of the cultural property and the allocation of ownership shares, insofar as division is possible; the restitution of the cultural property against compensation of the party returning it; the joint sale of the cultural property and the distribution of the proceeds between the parties in a specified proportion; compensation of the applicant; recognition of the cultural property and of its former rightful owners; or any other action or omission that appears to be a just and fair solution (cf. Art. 9 para. 2 CPCH Rules).

It should be noted that recommendations are adopted and reasoned by the Commission (cf. Art. 10 para. 1 CPCH Rules). The statement of reasons forms an integral part of the recommendation and is published at the same time, provided that no interest worthy of protection precludes this (cf. Art. 10 para. 2 CPCH Rules; see also Art. 7 OCPCP).

Under Art. 11 CPCH Rules, the Commission may delegate the preparation of recommendations to an ad hoc committee. Nevertheless, decision-making power lies solely with the Commission (cf. Explanatory Notes, p. 9).

Although the two procedures – mediation and the recommendation procedure – are distinct, as the Explanatory Notes to the CPCH Rules of Procedure point out, “[…] mediation is not tied to the opening of the procedure; it may be initiated at any time, at the request of a party or on the initiative of the President” (cf. Explanatory Notes, p. 5; our translation). Nevertheless, mediation requires the consent of all parties (cf. ibid.).

Conclusion

The creation of the Commission represents an important opportunity for museums, heritage institutions and private individuals faced with historically problematic cultural property, whether in connection with looting linked to National Socialism or acquisitions in a colonial context. Given such property and the requirements of the procedure adopted by the Commission, it is essential to anticipate the legal issues and to prepare the referral to the Commission rigorously. Our firm is at your disposal to assist you.

The content of this article does not constitute legal advice. One of the following lawyers will be pleased to advise you on your particular situation: