Skip to content

Medical liability and access to a complete medical record

Access to a complete medical record – a decisive step, but one that raises obstacles in practice

Access to a complete medical record proves to be a decisive step in the exercise of the patient’s rights in the context of medical liability. However, assembling a complete medical record proves in practice to be a step fraught with obstacles.

Medical notes, operative reports, test and imaging results, consent and information forms, correspondence between doctors, prescriptions, discharge letters, follow-up and rehabilitation reports, etc. – all these items form the core of the patient’s medical record.

However, gathering all of the documentation can prove to be an arduous task.

Multiple difficulties…

Often, the record turns out to be incomplete – some documents are missing – or the patient is faced with documents scattered in different places, the record being divided among various parties (hospital, medical practice, specialist, radiology, laboratory, insurer, rehabilitation, etc.).

Sometimes, transmission is slow or the format in which documents are transmitted is unsuitable. The record may even prove difficult to decipher because of medical jargon. Reluctance on the part of the holder of the record may also stand in the patient’s way, and uncertainties may arise as to the scope of the right of access.

Finally, without medical and legal knowledge, it may also be difficult for the patient to assess for themselves whether their record is complete.

Access to the complete medical record – what is at stake

Having a complete medical record in one’s possession is essential for several reasons. First, it serves to establish the facts where an irregularity is suspected. The medical record makes it possible to reconstruct, precisely and chronologically, the symptoms, examinations, diagnoses, treatments, medical decisions, complications, follow-up, etc.

Without it, it may be difficult to establish whether there has been a diagnostic error, a delay in care, inappropriate treatment, inadequate monitoring or a failure to inform the patient.

Second, a complete medical record is essential for preparing an expert assessment. Indeed, an expert can only give a sound opinion on the basis of a record with no unclear areas.

Finally, assembling a complete medical record may confirm a suspicion, but it may also show that there is no fault that can be sustained in law. In many cases, this step therefore serves to avoid action that is premature, poorly targeted or ultimately unjustified.

The central role of the right to consult one’s medical record, protected by law

The obstacles described above are not insurmountable. The patient has a major asset and an essential ally – even if it is sometimes little known: the right of access to one’s medical record.

The patient’s right of access to their medical record is fundamental and must be scrupulously respected. This right of access is a precondition for the patient’s exercise of fundamental prerogatives.

In Switzerland, the statutory right of access to the medical record is protected by the Federal Act on Data Protection (hereinafter FADP), in particular by Art. 25 FADP. As regards health data, Art. 25 para. 3 FADP provides that health data may be communicated to the data subject, with their consent, through a designated health professional.

In Geneva, it is Art. 55 of the Geneva Health Act (Loi sur la santé, hereinafter LS-GE) that enshrines the patient’s right to consult their record and to have its meaning explained to them, to be given the documents it contains or to have them sent to the health professional of their choice.

Arts 52 to 58 LS-GE, for their part, set out in particular the requirements governing the keeping and content of records – including electronic records – data processing and retention, as well as what becomes of the record when a practice ceases its activity.

Accordingly, any patient who has doubts about the care they have received has the right of access to their medical record.

The solution adopted in other countries: the shared medical record

Five countries are often cited among the most advanced examples of shared medical records: Estonia, Denmark, Finland, Israel and Singapore.

What they all have in common is that they have set up digital systems enabling authorised doctors to gain rapid access to a very broad overview of a patient’s care pathway – prescriptions, test results, hospital stays, reports or medical history.

On paper, the advantage is obvious and lies in better continuity of care, fewer repeated tests, faster medical decisions and, in principle, greater safety for the patient.

Moreover, these models show that extensive sharing of health data is technically possible, provided that it is based on a robust national infrastructure, clear access rules and regular input by health professionals.

However, these successes must be qualified. Even in these five States, there is no perfectly unified, exhaustive record that is open without restriction to all doctors.

In practice, everything still depends on the data actually entered into the system, on the level of integration between institutions, and on the limits imposed by confidentiality and the protection of sensitive data.

In other words, these countries have come close to a “near-complete” medical record, without, however, eliminating all grey areas.

Their experience shows both the promise of broader access to medical information and the persistent difficulties in building a truly universal record.

The limitations of the Swiss system and the need for assistance

In Switzerland, at present and despite the existence of the electronic patient record (EPR) – due to be replaced by the electronic health record (E-HR) by around 2030 – the level of integration found in certain countries has not been achieved. As a result, medical records scattered among several holders remain very common in practice.

Yet this situation places a significant administrative – and sometimes even emotional – burden on the patient concerned. It requires multiple requests to all the health professionals consulted and/or all the healthcare institutions concerned. However, each request will be dealt with according to its own timeframe and will result in the transmission of a multitude of documents in various formats. A genuine task of compiling and sorting – above all in chronological order – will therefore have to be carried out, often by the patient personally.

Even at this stage, it may be advisable to seek assistance. This is where the resources that a patient support organisation or a lawyer can offer come into play.

The content of this article does not constitute legal advice. One of the following lawyers will be pleased to advise you on your particular situation: