Skip to content

Revision of Swiss inheritance law

Major changes from 1 January 2023

I. Introduction

Swiss inheritance law is currently undergoing a two-stage revision, initiated following the filing of the “Gutzwiller” motion in 2010. This revision is welcome, as it makes it possible to adapt provisions, some of which date back to the entry into force of the Swiss Civil Code (hereinafter also: CC), to today’s family models.

The first part of the revision, mainly devoted to reducing statutory entitlements (compulsory portions), has the effect of increasing the freedom of disposition and allowing greater flexibility in estate planning.

The second part of the revision, for its part, aims to facilitate the transfer of family businesses. It will not, however, be discussed here, since it has not yet been dealt with by Parliament.

This article highlights the major changes made by the first part of the revision – which came into force on 1 January 2023 – so that everyone can assess their impact on his or her own future succession and take any measures that may be required.

II. The main changes

A. The reduction of statutory entitlements

The Swiss Civil Code designates the statutory heirs and sets the statutory share of the estate to which they are entitled. Certain heirs have a statutory entitlement, namely a specified part of their statutory share which, in principle, cannot be taken away from them. The statutory entitlement thus restricts the testator’s testamentary freedom, since it prevents him or her from disposing of all of his or her property as he or she sees fit.

Until 31 December 2022, descendants, the father and mother, and the surviving spouse or registered partner were heirs with a statutory entitlement (former Art. 470 para. 1 CC).

Since 1 January 2023, the father and mother have lost their statutory entitlement (Art. 470 para. 1 CC). Now, only descendants and the surviving spouse or registered partner still have a statutory entitlement.

The statutory entitlement of the surviving spouse or registered partner is the same as under the former law, namely one-half (½) of the statutory share. The statutory entitlement of descendants, on the other hand, is reduced to one-half (½) of their statutory succession rights, whereas it was three-quarters (¾) under the former law (Art. 471 CC).

As a result of the reduction of statutory entitlements, it is now always possible to dispose freely of at least half of the estate, which makes it easier to favour certain heirs, such as the surviving spouse or registered partner, a cohabiting partner or his or her children.

Since the new law applies to deaths occurring on or after 1 January 2023 (Arts 15 and 16 para. 3 Final Title CC), ambiguities are likely to arise frequently where successions governed by the new law must take into account wills or contracts of succession made under the former law.

The following example illustrates this risk. A childless testator stipulates in his will, drawn up in 2021, that his father and mother are to receive their statutory entitlement. Since 1 January 2023, parents are no longer heirs with a statutory entitlement. Consequently, in the absence of any clarification by the testator, it will be necessary to determine whether he wished his parents to receive what they would have received under the former law or, on the contrary, whether he wished them to receive the statutory minimum, which in this case means nothing at all under the new law.

To avoid any uncertainty and ambiguity, persons who made testamentary dispositions under the former law are advised to check that these comply with the new law and to make the necessary clarifications as soon as possible.

B. The disposable part where a usufruct is granted to the surviving spouse or registered partner

It is not uncommon for testamentary dispositions to favour the surviving spouse or registered partner by granting a usufruct.

Until 31 December 2022, the testator could favour his or her surviving spouse or registered partner by allocating one-quarter (¼) of the estate to him or her in full ownership and granting him or her a usufruct over the entire share passing to the common children, i.e. over three-quarters (¾) of the estate (former Art. 473 paras 1 and 2 CC).

The new law makes it possible to favour the surviving spouse or registered partner even further, since the testator may now allocate to him or her, in addition to the usufruct over the half (½) of the estate passing in bare ownership to the common descendants, one-half (½) of the estate in full ownership (Art. 473 paras 1 and 2 CC).

Accordingly, it would be advisable to review the content of wills and contracts of succession made under the former law, in order to take advantage of the new statutory provisions, which are more favourable to the surviving spouse or registered partner.

C. The effects of divorce proceedings or proceedings to dissolve a registered partnership on statutory entitlements

Under the former law, the divorce decree had to become final for the surviving spouse to lose, simultaneously, his or her status as a statutory heir and as an heir with a statutory entitlement (former Art. 120 para. 2 CC).

Now, the surviving spouse loses his or her right to claim the statutory entitlement if, at the time of death, divorce proceedings are pending and those proceedings were instigated or continued by joint request, or if the spouses have lived apart for at least two years (Art. 472 para. 1 CC).

A word of caution, however: Art. 472 para. 1 CC does not deprive the surviving spouse of his or her status as a statutory heir, which he or she retains until the divorce decree becomes final. A spouse who wishes to deprive the other spouse of that status must therefore make a testamentary disposition to that effect in his or her will or in a contract of succession.

Furthermore, unless otherwise provided, the pendency of divorce proceedings prevents the surviving spouse from raising claims based on testamentary dispositions that would favour him or her (Art. 120 para. 3 no. 2 CC). The same applies to clauses conferring benefits contained in a marital agreement (Arts 217 para. 2 and 241 para. 4 CC).

Finally, we note that the foregoing applies mutatis mutandis to registered partners.

D. Restricted retirement savings

The new inheritance law finally puts an end to the different treatment previously given to restricted retirement savings depending on their origin (bank or insurance).

As of 1 January 2023, retirement savings held with a bank no longer form part of the estate.

Nevertheless, although the beneficiaries have an independent right to receive these assets directly (Art. 82 para. 4 LPP), they may be abated if statutory entitlements are infringed. Their redemption value (for insurance-based retirement savings) or the account balance (for bank-based retirement savings) will be added to the estate for the purpose of calculating statutory entitlements (Art. 529 CC).

E. The order to be followed in the action in abatement

The revision of inheritance law has brought welcome clarifications regarding the action in abatement that an heir with a statutory entitlement may bring where his or her statutory entitlement has been infringed.

The new law now lists the acquisitions and gifts that may be abated in such an action (Art. 522 para. 1 CC), as well as the order to be followed to restore the infringed statutory entitlement (Art. 532 para. 1 CC).

Abatement applies first to acquisitions in accordance with the law on intestate succession (Art. 532 para. 1 no. 1 CC), which means that the first step is to reduce the statutory heirs’ share of the estate to their statutory entitlement.

Abatement then applies to bequests (Art. 532 para. 1 no. 2 CC) and, finally, to inter vivos gifts (Art. 532 para. 1 no. 3 CC).

It is worth noting here that the new law has finally put an end to the doctrinal controversy over the classification of gifts made by marital agreement, since it expressly states that they are inter vivos gifts (Art. 532 para. 2 no. 1 CC) and not bequests.

F. Contracts of succession and the prohibition of subsequent gifts

Under the former law, a person who had concluded a contract of succession could still freely dispose of his or her property and make inter vivos gifts, provided that the contract did not exclude this possibility and that such gifts were not made with the intention of harming the heirs (ATF 140 III 193).

Since 1 January 2023, a person who concludes – or has concluded – a contract of succession has his or her freedom of disposition restricted, since he or she may no longer make inter vivos gifts – with the exception of customary occasional gifts – where the contract of succession has not made provision for this possibility and the gifts are incompatible with the obligations under the contract.

In other words, testamentary dispositions and inter vivos gifts exceeding customary occasional gifts may now be challenged where they are incompatible with the obligations under the contract and the contract has not made provision for them (Art. 494 para. 3 CC).

This reversal of the principle applied until now will have far-reaching consequences, since the new law applies to all deaths occurring on or after 1 January 2023 (Arts 15 and 16 para. 3 Final Title CC), including where contracts of succession were concluded and gifts made before 1 January 2023.

We therefore recommend that persons who have concluded a contract of succession review its content and amend it promptly, specifying in particular whether or not they may freely dispose of their property after concluding the contract. If the contracting parties wish to retain some room for manoeuvre, they should add a reservation to that effect to the existing contract of succession or conclude a new one, which may define the permitted inter vivos gifts.

III. Conclusion

Flexibility and greater freedom of disposition: this is how the revision of inheritance law that came into force on 1 January of this year can be summed up. Thanks to it, it is now easier to favour the surviving spouse or registered partner, a cohabiting partner, his or her children or even third parties.

Since the new law applies to successions opening on or after 1 January 2023, it is important that anyone who drew up a will or concluded a contract of succession before that date checks that it complies with the new law and makes the necessary clarifications.

While it is true that the reduction of statutory entitlements has removed one obstacle to the transfer of a business within a family, the fact remains that this is not sufficient.

The second part of the revision of inheritance law, which is due to be dealt with by Parliament during 2023, should remedy this through the three key measures it provides for, namely:

  1. the possibility for the heir taking over the business to claim the right to be allocated the entire business (or all the shareholdings forming part of the estate), even where the deceased has made no provision to that effect (Art. 617 para. 1 draft CC);
  2. the possibility for the heir taking over the business to obtain deferred payment of his or her co-heirs’ claims arising from the succession for a maximum of 5 years, where settling them would cause him or her serious difficulties likely to prevent the takeover of the business (Art. 619 draft CC); and
  3. the possibility of taking into account the value of the business at the time the gift is made, and no longer only on the date of the deceased’s death, where the business is transferred in whole or in part during his or her lifetime and must be brought into hotchpot for the division of the estate (Art. 633a draft CC).

The content of this article does not constitute legal advice. One of the following lawyers will be pleased to advise you on your particular situation: