I. Introduction
The Federal Act on Insurance Policies (Insurance Policies Act, IPA) governs, under private law, the contractual relationship between a policyholder and an insurer.
The Act applies to insurance taken out by personal choice rather than because of a legal obligation. This is the case in particular for life, liability, household contents and supplementary health insurance, but not for basic health insurance, which is governed by the Federal Act on Health Insurance (HIA).
Initiated several years ago, the partial revision of the IPA has finally been completed and entered into force on 1 January 2022. The purpose of this article is to highlight the major changes brought about by this partial revision, so that everyone can quickly assess their consequences for existing policies and/or policies yet to be concluded.
II. The main changes
A. The 14-day right of revocation
Under Art. 2a para. 1 IPA, the policyholder may revoke their application for the contract or their acceptance of it, in writing or in any other form that may be evidenced by text. The revocation period is 14 days and begins to run as soon as the policyholder has applied for or accepted the contract (para. 2).
Revocation of the insurance contract has ex tunc effect, so that the parties must be restored to the position they would have been in had the contract not been concluded (Art. 2b IPA; Federal Council Dispatch of 28 June 2017, p. 4787). It is, however, conceivable that the policyholder may be required to reimburse the insurer for costs incurred for medical or technical examinations carried out with a view to concluding the contract.
Arts 2a and 2b IPA are semi-mandatory provisions (Art. 98 IPA), which cannot be derogated from to the detriment of the weaker party, in this case the policyholder.
In the context of collective personal insurance, provisional cover and agreements with a term of less than one month, the right of revocation is excluded (Art. 2a para. 4 IPA). It should be noted, however, that provisional cover that is not limited in time may be terminated subject to 14 days’ notice (Art. 9 para. 3 IPA).
B. The ordinary right of termination after three years
Regardless of the contractual term agreed by the parties, they may terminate the insurance contract, in writing or in any other form that allows proof thereof, at the end of the third year of insurance or of any subsequent year, subject to three months’ notice (Art. 35a para. 1 IPA).
In practice, this means that a contract you may have concluded for a term of five years to insure your car can be terminated after three or four years, subject to three months’ notice to the end of a year.
In the context of supplementary health insurance, Art. 35a para. 4 sentence 1 IPA provides that only the policyholder may rely on this ordinary right of termination, as well as on the right of termination in the event of a loss (Art. 42 para. 1 IPA), to the exclusion, therefore, of the insurer. The position is different for collective daily allowance insurance, since in that context both parties may terminate the contract on an ordinary basis and in the event of a loss (Art. 35a para. 4 sentence 2 IPA).
The foregoing does not, however, apply to life insurance contracts. Although governed by the IPA, they do not benefit from the ordinary right of termination enshrined in Art. 35a para. 1 IPA, with the result that neither the policyholder nor the insurer can rely on it (Art. 35a para. 3 IPA).
As Art. 35a IPA is a semi-mandatory provision (Art. 98 IPA), it cannot be derogated from to the detriment of the weaker party, namely the policyholder.
C. The direct right of action against liability insurers
Art. 60 para. 1bis IPA is a mandatory provision (Art. 97 IPA) which introduces a direct right of action for the injured third party or their legal successor against the insurance company, within the limits of existing insurance cover and subject to the objections and defences that the insurer may raise against the policyholder under the law or the contract.
In other words, this direct right of action now allows the injured party to assert their claims directly against the liability insurer of the person who caused the loss, even though the former has no contractual relationship with the insurer.
It is important to be aware that the insurance company may raise against the injured party the objections and defences arising from the law or the insurance contract only in the context of non-compulsory liability insurance (Brulhart Vincent, La généralisation du droit d’action directe dans l’assurance de la responsabilité civile: Au rythme des saisons, in La Revue de l’avocat 2021, p. 322). Art. 59 para. 3 IPA indeed provides that “in the case of compulsory liability insurance, defences arising from insured events caused intentionally or through gross negligence, from breaches of obligations, from non-payment of premiums or from a contractually agreed deductible may not be raised against the injured party” (our translation).
In order to ensure that the injured third party or their legal successor actually has the opportunity to exercise the direct right of action in cases involving compulsory liability insurance, the legislature has entitled them to require the liable insured person or the competent supervisory authority to inform them of the identity of the relevant insurance company (Art. 60 para. 3 IPA).
D. The limitation period increases from two to five years
Claims arising from an insurance contract are now, in principle, time-barred five years after the occurrence of the event giving rise to the entitlement to benefits, compared with two years until 31 December 2021 (Art. 46 IPA). It should be noted that occupational pension benefits are subject to their own specific regime.
Claims arising from a collective daily sickness allowance insurance contract nevertheless remain subject to a two-year limitation period, which begins to run from the occurrence of the event giving rise to the obligation (Art. 46 para. 3 IPA). According to the Federal Council Dispatch, it would not have been appropriate to provide for a five-year limitation period for these claims, since they concern temporary benefits relating to a short-term incapacity for work, which cannot be accurately assessed five years later (Federal Council Dispatch of 28 June 2017, p. 4799).
As Art. 46 IPA is a semi-mandatory provision (Art. 98 IPA), the parties may derogate from it only in favour of the weaker party.
E. The relaxation of formal requirements
The revision of the IPA relaxes the formal requirements. It is now broadly possible to communicate one’s decisions “in a form that may be evidenced by text” (our translation), as the written form with a handwritten or electronic signature is very often no longer required.
Thanks to this wording, the parties to insurance contracts may, in particular, communicate their decisions to terminate or revoke the contract by e-mail or fax (Federal Council Dispatch of 28 June 2017, p. 4776). Such communications may also be made via a platform or portal specific to the insurer.
The formal requirements have not, however, been relaxed for acceptances of provisional cover, which must still be confirmed in writing (Art. 9 para. 4 IPA).
III. The more marginal changes
A. The options available where the insured risk decreases
In the event of a significant decrease in the insured risk, Art. 28a IPA offers the policyholder two alternatives: they may (1) exercise their right to terminate the contract, subject to four weeks’ notice, or, alternatively, (2) their right to obtain a reduction in the premium.
It should be noted that the criteria for determining whether a decrease in the insured risk is significant will be examined and defined according to the circumstances of the specific case and to practice.
Once again, this provision is semi-mandatory (Art. 98 IPA).
B. Retroactive insurance
Art. 10 para. 1 IPA allows the parties to conclude an insurance contract which covers, in particular, a period prior to its conclusion.
In order to prevent abuse, the legislature has provided that retroactive insurance is void if only the policyholder knew or should have known that a loss had already occurred (Art. 10 para. 2 IPA; Federal Council Dispatch of 28 June 2017, p. 4791).
C. The impossibility of limiting the duration or scope of benefits where the contract ends after the insured event has occurred
Since 1 January 2022, provisions contained in the insurance contract may no longer, on pain of nullity, provide for the unilateral cancellation or limitation of the duration or scope of the obligation to provide benefits following an illness or accident where the illness or accident occurred before the end of the contract (Art. 35c para. 1 IPA).
Such a provision will undoubtedly play an essential role in the case of illnesses that take some time to be diagnosed.
IV. Transitional law
The question that inevitably arises is whether the amendments to the IPA – and in particular those mentioned above – apply only to contracts concluded from 1 January 2022, i.e. the date on which the revision of the IPA entered into force, or also retroactively to those concluded up to 31 December 2021.
Art. 103a IPA answers this question by providing for the partial application of the new statutory provisions to existing contracts. Indeed, only Arts 35a and 35b IPA on the ordinary and extraordinary right to terminate the contract, together with the relaxed formal requirements, apply to contracts concluded up to 31 December 2021.
Notwithstanding the foregoing, it is entirely possible that some insurance companies will decide to amend their general terms and conditions so that contracts existing on 31 December 2021 also benefit from the new statutory provisions.
By way of illustration, and unless otherwise agreed in a manner more favourable to the policyholder, the five-year limitation period does not apply to events giving rise to an entitlement that occurred before 31 December 2021.
V. Conclusion
It appears that the amendments made by the partial revision of the IPA are largely favourable to policyholders, who can rely on more rights against the insurer.
Moreover, the fact that the new provisions are very often mandatory or semi-mandatory demonstrates the legislature’s desire to provide greater protection for policyholders.
It is therefore important for policyholders to consult the general terms and conditions applicable to contracts concluded before 31 December 2021 in order to find out whether their insurers have decided to bring them into line with the new statutory provisions for those contracts as well.
The content of this article does not constitute legal advice. One of the following lawyers will be pleased to advise you on your particular situation: